diff --git a/tests/experimental/artifacts/rto-focused-vs-global-focused.json b/tests/experimental/artifacts/rto-focused-vs-global-focused.json index 68a199c..0647cda 100644 --- a/tests/experimental/artifacts/rto-focused-vs-global-focused.json +++ b/tests/experimental/artifacts/rto-focused-vs-global-focused.json @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ "path": "focused", "targetNodeId": "nxmeiab", "modelName": "qwen-claude:latest", - "modelElapsedMs": 55405, + "modelElapsedMs": 51195, "inputCharacterCount": 2405, "structuredResult": { "targetNodeId": "nxmeiab", @@ -10,39 +10,39 @@ "Two competitors have publicly announced products aimed at the same customer problem.", "One competitor expects a beta release within six months.", "The other competitor has not announced a release date.", - "The degree of functional overlap between either competitor's product and ours is currently unknown." + "It is currently unknown how closely either competing product matches our own." ], "uncertainties": [ - "How closely Competitor 1's product matches our functionality.", - "How closely Competitor 2's product matches our functionality.", - "When or if Competitor 2 will announce a release date for their product." + "How soon the first competitor will progress beyond the beta stage to a general release.", + "Whether the second competitor will eventually publish a release timeline or development milestones.", + "The degree of functional and market overlap between the competing products and our own." ], "assumptions": [], "relationships": [ { - "from": "Competitor 1", - "to": "Beta release within six months", - "type": "projects", - "rationale": "Directly stated by the competitor regarding their product timeline." + "from": "Competitor with beta announcement", + "to": "six-month timeline", + "type": "announces_target_release_window", + "rationale": "Answer explicitly states one competitor expects a beta within six months." }, { - "from": "Competitor 2", - "to": "No announced release date", - "type": "undisclosed", - "rationale": "Explicitly noted as unannounced in public communications." + "from": "Second Competitor", + "to": "Release date", + "type": "lacks_public_commitment", + "rationale": "Answer explicitly notes the other competitor has not announced a release date." }, { - "from": "Our product", - "to": "Competitors' products", - "type": "unknown functional alignment", - "rationale": "Answer explicitly states the degree of matching features or capabilities is currently unknown." + "from": "Competing products", + "to": "Our product", + "type": "unknown_similarity", + "rationale": "Answer states we do not yet know how closely either product matches ours." } ], "possibleFollowUpQuestions": [ - "What specific features or capabilities in our product are addressed by the competitors' announcements?", - "Has Competitor 2 provided any indirect signals about development progress despite lacking a formal release date?", - "How does the target customer problem for our product compare in scope or priority to the competitors' stated problem?", - "What engineering or market validation metrics would confirm if either competitor's product poses an immediate threat to our launch timeline?" + "How closely do the announced features of the competitors align with our core value proposition?", + "What is the reliability and historical track record of the six-month beta timeline?", + "Has the competitor without a stated date provided any technical previews or development milestones?", + "Can we quantify how a six-month beta release would impact our target enterprise customer's decision?" ] } } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tests/experimental/artifacts/rto-focused-vs-global-global.json b/tests/experimental/artifacts/rto-focused-vs-global-global.json index ff32b08..d1c1094 100644 --- a/tests/experimental/artifacts/rto-focused-vs-global-global.json +++ b/tests/experimental/artifacts/rto-focused-vs-global-global.json @@ -2,37 +2,37 @@ "path": "global", "targetNodeId": "nxmeiab", "modelName": "qwen-claude:latest", - "modelElapsedMs": 88348, + "modelElapsedMs": 100584, "providerGenerateCalls": 1, "providerTimingCaptured": true, - "endToEndElapsedMs": 88358, + "endToEndElapsedMs": 100600, "inputCharacterCount": 22112, "graphUpdateResultSummary": { - "userSupportedMeaning": "Two competitors have announced targeted products; one expects a beta in six months, the other has no release date yet, and it is unknown how closely either matches our solution.", - "possibleInference": "Competitive pressure is imminent for at least one product, suggesting we cannot wait indefinitely without risk of losing first-mover advantage to the sooner launcher.", + "userSupportedMeaning": "Two competitors have announced products for the same problem, with one beta in six months and one unannounced, but it is currently unknown how closely either product matches ours.", + "possibleInference": "The confirmed competitor launches may shorten our viable launch window, increasing pressure to launch sooner or differentiate sharply.", "proposalValidation": { "success": false, "errors": [] }, "selectedQuestion": { - "nodeId": "ncomp_fit", - "question": "How closely does our product match the capabilities of the two announced competitor offerings?", - "reason": "This remaining uncertainty determines whether the imminent competitor launches pose an immediate threat to launching now." + "nodeId": "ncp_match_unknown", + "question": "How closely does our product match the functionality or customer needs of the two announced competitor products?", + "reason": "This remaining uncertainty determines whether the competitors' timeline poses a material threat to our launch timing." } }, "answerDerivedComparisonExtraction": { "observations": [ - "Two competitors have announced targeted products; one expects a beta in six months, the other has no release date yet, and it is unknown how closely either matches our solution." + "Two competitors have announced products for the same problem, with one beta in six months and one unannounced, but it is currently unknown how closely either product matches ours." ], "uncertainties": [ - "Competitive pressure is imminent for at least one product, suggesting we cannot wait indefinitely without risk of losing first-mover advantage to the sooner launcher." + "The confirmed competitor launches may shorten our viable launch window, increasing pressure to launch sooner or differentiate sharply." ], "assumptions": "not directly exposed", "relationships": "not directly exposed", "newlySurfacedUnknownsOrQuestions": { - "nodeId": "ncomp_fit", - "question": "How closely does our product match the capabilities of the two announced competitor offerings?", - "reason": "This remaining uncertainty determines whether the imminent competitor launches pose an immediate threat to launching now." + "nodeId": "ncp_match_unknown", + "question": "How closely does our product match the functionality or customer needs of the two announced competitor products?", + "reason": "This remaining uncertainty determines whether the competitors' timeline poses a material threat to our launch timing." } } } \ No newline at end of file