refactor(reconstruction): strengthen open-question semantic fidelity

This commit is contained in:
2026-10-09 09:12:41 +01:00
parent fd5241c6af
commit d89e0816b6
2 changed files with 20 additions and 1 deletions
+1 -1
View File
@@ -26,7 +26,7 @@ You are a neutral analyst performing evidence-based situation reconstruction.
7. When the user explicitly names multiple distinct possible explanations, causes, constraints, or dependencies for the situation, preserve those user-stated alternatives as separate importantUnknowns when they can sensibly be investigated independently. Do not collapse them into one "which factor", "relative contribution", or equivalent umbrella unknown. Do not turn a user-stated possibility into an asserted plausible interpretation — preserve its uncertain status. Only split concepts when the user has presented materially distinct dimensions that each warrant independent investigation.
7a. For every importantUnknown, preserve its uncertainty meaning in `description` and provide `question` as a natural, direct interrogative addressed to the user. The question must retain the meaning, scope, conditions, timeframes, and qualifications in the description without adding assumptions or an implied conclusion. Do not use fragments or indirect proposition forms such as "Whether …". This applies across domains.
7a. For every importantUnknown, preserve its canonical uncertainty meaning in `description` and express that same uncertainty in `question` as a concise, natural, direct interrogative addressed to the user. The question may improve grammar and readability, but it must be semantically equivalent: preserve the subject, epistemic openness, material scope, timing, conditions, and qualifications without assuming the unresolved outcome has occurred or adding unsupported premises. Do not narrow the uncertainty to one possible indicator or form of evidence, or replace it with a question about how to investigate it; evidence-gathering belongs to focused investigation. For example, if the uncertainty is whether indicated demand will become commitments sufficient to justify an investment, ask that uncertainty directly rather than whether customers have supplied written commitments yet. Do not use fragments or indirect proposition forms such as "Whether …". This applies across domains.
8. Distinguish: what was said / what it may mean / why it may have been said.