{ "description": "Deterministic pre-anchored decision-options fixture — represents the successful 60A.6 persistent reasoning state.", "scenario": "We are evaluating two relocation options: moving the engineering team to Manchester or staying in London.", "unresolved_question": "Which option leaves us better off overall?", "graph": { "centralStatement": "We are evaluating two relocation options: moving the engineering team to Manchester or staying in London.", "nodes": [ { "id": "n_relocation_state", "label": "Engineering team relocation consideration", "description": "Current state: the organisation is evaluating whether to relocate its engineering team from London to Manchester for cost reduction.", "kind": "state", "status": "provisional", "confidence": "high", "value": null, "unit": null, "evidenceIds": [], "dependsOn": [], "affects": [], "parentId": null, "childIds": [] }, { "id": "opt_relocate", "label": "Relocate to Manchester", "description": "Move the engineering team to Manchester. Consequences: save £2M/year, lose two senior engineers, delivery delay <= two months.", "kind": "option", "status": "known", "confidence": "high", "value": null, "unit": null, "evidenceIds": [], "dependsOn": [], "affects": [], "parentId": null, "childIds": [] }, { "id": "opt_stay_put", "label": "Stay in London (Status Quo)", "description": "Remain at the current London office. Consequences: retain both senior engineers, avoid relocation delay, continue paying extra £2M/year.", "kind": "option", "status": "known", "confidence": "high", "value": null, "unit": null, "evidenceIds": [], "dependsOn": [], "affects": [], "parentId": null, "childIds": [] }, { "id": "n_relocation_decision", "label": "Which option leaves us better off overall?", "description": "Uncertainty about which of the two relocation options — relocate to Manchester or stay in London — provides superior net value for the organisation.", "kind": "unknown", "status": "unknown", "confidence": "medium", "value": null, "unit": null, "evidenceIds": [], "dependsOn": [], "affects": [], "parentId": null, "childIds": [] } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-opt-rel-to-dec", "fromNodeId": "opt_relocate", "toNodeId": "n_relocation_decision", "relationship": "contained_in", "confidence": "high", "description": "Relocate to Manchester option is a candidate for the relocation decision" }, { "id": "e-opt-stay-to-dec", "fromNodeId": "opt_stay_put", "toNodeId": "n_relocation_decision", "relationship": "contained_in", "confidence": "high", "description": "Stay in London option is a candidate for the relocation decision" } ], "activeUnknownNodeId": "n_relocation_decision", "resolvedNodeIds": [], "currentSummary": "Two relocation options evaluated; net-value comparison unresolved.", "reasoningState": { "comparabilityStatus": null, "relationshipStatus": null, "relationshipAssessed": false, "contradictionReasoningAllowed": true, "reasoningStages": [] } } }