# Diagnostic Case: diag-03 Apparent contradiction — sales down but revenue up after price change. Distinguishes volume vs value. ## Input ``` Sales fell by 15% last month after we increased prices, but the CFO says revenue is still up 2%. ``` ## Result - **Technical**: ❌ FAIL (0/4 sub-checks pass) - **Reasoning Quality**: ❌ FAIL (0/2 sub-checks pass) - **Actual Primary Type**: causal_claim - **Actual Reasoning Modes**: establish_baseline, identify_difference - **Response Duration**: 1ms ### Technical Failures classification mismatch ### Reasoning Quality Failures missing required concept(s): sales decline, price increase, revenue increase, CFO report