{ "success": true, "stage": "update_applied", "situationGraph": { "centralStatement": "Complaint counts increased while production also increased.", "nodes": [ { "id": "n-obs-1", "label": "Customer complaints rose by 35% over the last six months", "description": "Customer complaints rose by 35% over the last six months", "kind": "observation", "status": "supported", "confidence": "high", "value": null, "unit": null, "evidenceIds": [ "complaint-data" ], "dependsOn": [], "affects": [], "parentId": null, "childIds": [] }, { "id": "n-obs-2", "label": "Production volume increased by 40% in the same period", "description": "Production volume increased by 40% in the same period", "kind": "observation", "status": "supported", "confidence": "high", "value": null, "unit": null, "evidenceIds": [ "production-data" ], "dependsOn": [], "affects": [], "parentId": null, "childIds": [] }, { "id": "n-obs-3", "label": "A new CRM tagging system was introduced three months ago", "description": "A new CRM tagging system was introduced three months ago, coinciding with the complaint category changes", "kind": "observation", "status": "known", "confidence": "high", "value": null, "unit": null, "evidenceIds": [ "crm-audit" ], "dependsOn": [], "affects": [], "parentId": null, "childIds": [] }, { "id": "n-unknown-1", "label": "Whether complaints increased per-unit or proportionally with production volume", "description": "Need to know the complaint rate normalized by production volume to determine if quality deteriorated or if growth explains the rise", "kind": "unknown", "status": "unknown", "confidence": "high", "value": null, "unit": null, "evidenceIds": [], "dependsOn": [], "affects": [ "n-conclusion" ], "parentId": null, "childIds": [] }, { "id": "n-unknown-2", "label": "Whether the new CRM tagging system changed what gets counted as a complaint", "description": "The complaint category changes may be an artifact of the new CRM system rather than genuine quality change", "kind": "unknown", "status": "unknown", "confidence": "medium", "value": null, "unit": null, "evidenceIds": [], "dependsOn": [], "affects": [ "n-unknown-1" ], "parentId": null, "childIds": [] }, { "id": "n-conclusion", "label": "Whether automated quality inspection investment is justified", "description": "Decision node for whether to spend about £120,000 on automated quality inspection", "kind": "state", "status": "provisional", "confidence": "medium", "value": null, "unit": null, "evidenceIds": [], "dependsOn": [ "n-unknown-1" ], "affects": [], "parentId": null, "childIds": [] }, { "id": "nz92pkx-summary", "label": "Complaint counts increased while production also increased.", "description": "Summary of the situation from the scenario text", "kind": "state", "status": "provisional", "confidence": "medium", "value": null, "unit": null, "evidenceIds": [], "dependsOn": [ "n-obs-1", "n-obs-2", "n-obs-3" ], "affects": [ "n-conclusion" ], "parentId": null, "childIds": [] } ], "edges": [ { "id": "e-evidence-n-obs-1", "fromNodeId": "n-obs-1", "toNodeId": "nz92pkx-summary", "relationship": "supports", "confidence": "high", "description": "Customer complaints rose by 35% over the last six months supports the summary" }, { "id": "e-evidence-n-obs-2", "fromNodeId": "n-obs-2", "toNodeId": "nz92pkx-summary", "relationship": "supports", "confidence": "high", "description": "Production volume increased by 40% in the same period supports the summary" }, { "id": "e-evidence-n-obs-3", "fromNodeId": "n-obs-3", "toNodeId": "nz92pkx-summary", "relationship": "supports", "confidence": "high", "description": "A new CRM tagging system was introduced three months ago supports the summary" }, { "id": "e-unk-n-unknown-1", "fromNodeId": "n-unknown-1", "toNodeId": "nz92pkx-summary", "relationship": "depends_on", "confidence": "high", "description": "Whether complaints increased per-unit or proportionally with production volume is an unresolved factor for this situation" }, { "id": "e-unk-n-unknown-2", "fromNodeId": "n-unknown-2", "toNodeId": "nz92pkx-summary", "relationship": "depends_on", "confidence": "medium", "description": "Whether the new CRM tagging system changed what gets counted as a complaint is an unresolved factor for this situation" }, { "id": "e-unk-conclusion", "fromNodeId": "n-unknown-1", "toNodeId": "n-conclusion", "relationship": "depends_on", "confidence": "medium", "description": "Whether complaints increased per-unit or proportionally with production volume affects the investment decision" } ], "activeUnknownNodeId": "n-unknown-1", "resolvedNodeIds": [], "currentSummary": "Nodes: 4 observation, 2 unknown, 2 state | Edges: 6 total | Unknowns: 2 unresolved" }, "findings": [ { "id": "finding-complaint-rise", "proposition": "Customer complaints have increased by 35% over the last six months while production volume grew by 40%.", "status": "provisional", "userDisposition": null, "originatingTargetNodeId": "n-unknown-1", "contributionId": "contrib-admission-1", "sourceObservation": "user_input" }, { "id": "finding-crm-change", "proposition": "A new CRM tagging system was introduced three months ago, coinciding with complaint category changes.", "status": "provisional", "userDisposition": null, "originatingTargetNodeId": "n-unknown-2", "contributionId": "contrib-admission-2", "sourceObservation": "user_input" } ], "selectedQuestion": { "nodeId": "n-unknown-1", "question": "What is the complaint rate normalized by production volume, and has it increased per unit?", "reason": "The admitted evidence shows absolute increases but does not establish whether quality deteriorated or growth explains the rise.", "strategy": "evidence_gathering", "investigationStrategy": { "key": "evidence_gathering", "reason": "Resolving the unknown requires normalized rate data.", "nodeId": "n-unknown-1", "nodeLabel": "Whether complaints increased per-unit or proportionally with production volume", "meaning": "whether complaints increased per-unit or proportionally with production volume", "actionPhrase": "deciding whether to spend about £120,000 on automated quality inspection now", "relatedNodeIds": [ "n-conclusion" ], "centralStatement": "Complaint counts increased while production also increased." }, "reasoningPattern": "decision", "reasoningPatternReason": "Selected decision because the active unknown sits inside an investment justification context." }, "diagnostics": { "promptVersion": "v0.4", "modelName": "configured-model", "validationStatus": "valid", "nodeCount": 6, "edgeCount": 6, "graphReferenceValidation": { "valid": true, "errors": [] }, "unknownSelectionExplanation": { "selectedNodeId": "n-unknown-1", "status": "selected", "tieType": "none" } } }